Your Marketing Problem Isn't Marketing. It's Messaging.
When marketing isn't breaking through, the problem usually sits one level up: the company has never decided what it wants to say.
There's a pattern I've seen inside a lot of otherwise sophisticated organizations.
The marketing team is busy. Very busy.
They're launching campaigns, rebuilding landing pages, producing content, feeding social channels, briefing agencies, developing sales materials, managing paid media, planning events, refreshing presentations, and endlessly debating headlines.
And somewhere along the way, someone says:
"Our marketing just isn't breaking through."
So the organization responds the way organizations usually do.
Increase the media budget.
Try a different campaign.
Redesign the website.
Change agencies.
Create more content.
Refresh the brand.
Add another promotion.
Sometimes those things help.
But quite often, the actual problem sits one level above all of them.
The organization has never really decided what it wants to say.
Not its tagline.
Not its mission statement.
Not the three adjectives in its brand guidelines.
I mean the actual strategic messaging that answers some deceptively difficult questions:
Why should someone choose us?
What do we believe that our competitors don't?
What problem do we solve better than anyone else?
Why should that matter to the customer?
What should people remember about us when we're not in the room?
And perhaps most importantly:
Can everyone in the organization answer those questions roughly the same way? Can your other stakeholders, like your suppliers or your community? Can your customers?
For many companies, the answer is no.
And that messaging problem quietly becomes a marketing problem, an advertising problem, a sales problem, a culture problem, and eventually a performance problem.
Most Companies Have More Messaging Than They Realize
One of the biggest misconceptions about messaging is that companies don't have it.
They do. They have tons of it. It's just rarely organized.
The homepage says one thing. The sales presentation says another. Recruiting talks about the company one way. The CEO describes the organization another. The sales team has developed its own language. Customer service has another explanation. The latest ad campaign is already introducing a new idea, and the agency, trying to create something interesting, adds another layer.
Take any one of these messages, and it may be great. One of them may even be the most powerful thing the organization could say.
The problem is that when there's more than one story being told, they compete with one another.
The result is what I think of as organizational message drift, and left unchecked, it can have huge and unanticipated consequences. Over time, dozens of individually reasonable decisions gradually pull the brand in different directions.
Marketing starts sounding like marketing.
Sales starts sounding like sales.
Leadership talks about vision.
HR talks about culture.
Operations talks about capability.
And customers are left to figure out what the company actually stands for.
IBM: From Scattered Campaigns to One Idea the Market Could Own
Before: IBM had plenty to say. That was the problem.
When Lou Gerstner took over IBM in 1993, the company had technology problems. It also had an enormous coherence problem.
In 1994, Gerstner's team took IBM's advertising, spread across several agencies in what amounted to a scattershot approach to selling its many products, and moved the whole $500 million account to one worldwide agency, Ogilvy & Mather.1
Think about that for a moment. You can imagine how easily individual product groups, business units and geographies could each have been telling technically accurate but strategically disconnected versions of the IBM story.
Meanwhile, the business itself was in serious trouble. IBM lost $8.1 billion in 1993, Gerstner's first year.2
Gerstner's fix started further up: deciding what larger story IBM wanted to own.
After: "e-business" gave the entire company a strategic narrative.
As commercial use of the internet began accelerating, IBM recognized something important: what businesses would need most was help figuring out what this new connected world meant for them.
IBM's marketing organization eventually gave that idea a simple name: e-business.
The phrase became far more than an advertising headline. It gave IBM a framework for connecting servers, software, consulting, networking and services around one customer-centered idea: we can help you do real business on the internet.
IBM committed roughly $500 million to the campaign. The spend matters less than the consistency.
The advertising dramatized e-business.
Sales could sell e-business.
Consultants could implement e-business.
Product groups could explain their technology through e-business.
Executives could talk to investors about e-business.
IBM Research could orient innovation around the problems created by e-business.
Eventually the market began associating the category with IBM itself.
By 1999, IBM says it was providing e-business services to more than 10,000 clients, and unaided association between IBM and "e-business" was seven times greater than that of its nearest competitor. From 1994 to 2000, IBM's revenue increased nearly 40% to more than $88 billion while net income nearly tripled. Those results can't be attributed to messaging alone, but IBM itself identifies the e-business strategy and campaign as an important part of its turnaround.3
Gerstner later described what the messaging had accomplished:
"We found our voice, our confidence and our ability once again to drive the industry agenda."3
That's a much bigger outcome than better advertising. IBM went from communicating products to owning an idea. And once the organization knew which idea it wanted to own, hundreds of individual marketing decisions became easier.
Why This Matters
This is probably the cleanest example of what happens when messaging architecture works correctly. The architecture organized IBM's enormous portfolio without eliminating any of it.
After: One strategic idea → multiple capabilities → hundreds of expressions of the same message.
That's marketing pull-through. And it's also why consistency shouldn't be confused with saying the same sentence repeatedly. IBM wasn't repeating one advertisement. It was repeatedly adding evidence to one idea.
The First Mistake: Treating Messaging Like Copywriting
This is probably the most common mistake. Messaging often gets addressed only when someone needs words.
"We need website messaging."
"We need campaign messaging."
"We need a new tagline."
"We need better ad copy."
Those are copywriting assignments. Strategic messaging comes before copywriting.
Messaging is the decision about what ideas deserve repetition. Copywriting is how those ideas are expressed in a particular context.
If the underlying message hasn't been decided, every new campaign becomes an exercise in reinventing the company.
Your paid media agency invents positioning for the ads.
Your web agency invents positioning for the website.
Your social team invents positioning for Instagram.
Your salespeople invent positioning in conversations.
And eventually the organization accumulates five or six different versions of itself.
A good messaging strategy does the opposite: it creates a shared strategic center. The creative expression can change. The audience can change. The channel can change. The campaign can change. But the fundamental ideas remain recognizable.
That's how brands become memorable.
The Second Mistake: Saying Too Much
Most companies struggle with messaging because they have too little clarity, not too little information.
Ask a leadership team why customers should choose the company and you'll often get something like:
"We have great people, great service, deep expertise, innovative solutions, a strong culture, competitive pricing, decades of experience, great technology, and we really care about our customers."
All of those things may be true. They're also nearly impossible to market.
Marketing requires prioritization. You cannot ask an audience to remember eight things. You're lucky if they remember one.
Strong messaging forces an uncomfortable strategic question: Of everything we could say, what is most important for people to understand?
That means some perfectly good ideas have to become secondary. That can be surprisingly difficult internally, because organizations tend to confuse completeness with clarity.
But customers reward relevance over completeness. The goal is to make the most important idea impossible to miss.
The Third Mistake: Confusing Differentiation With Cleverness
When companies realize their messaging sounds generic, they often try to fix it with creativity. The language becomes punchier. The headlines become more provocative. The campaign concept gets more interesting.
But clever language cannot rescue an undifferentiated idea.
"People first."
"Built differently."
"Solutions that move you forward."
"Experience the difference."
You've seen versions of these phrases thousands of times. The writing may be fine. The underlying strategic thought could belong to almost anyone.
Real differentiation usually comes from a more substantive place.
The way you operate.
The customer you understand unusually well.
A belief about your industry.
A tradeoff you're willing to make.
A particular experience you've designed.
A specialized capability.
A business model competitors struggle to replicate.
A philosophy that changes how you make decisions.
Often the most durable difference is what you believe and what you're willing to stand for.
Great messaging discovers that difference and turns it into language people can understand. It doesn't invent differentiation through adjectives.
Where This Starts Showing Up in Marketing
This is where messaging stops being a branding discussion and becomes a business performance discussion.
When messaging is unclear, campaign development becomes unnecessarily expensive. Every campaign begins from zero. Creative teams ask:
What are we trying to say?
What's the hook?
What's the value proposition?
What makes us different?
What should the call to action be?
Those questions should be asked. But the campaign team shouldn't have to rediscover the strategic answer every time.
Without a messaging framework, creative development becomes strategic archaeology. Everyone digs around the organization looking for something interesting to say. That slows production, increases revisions, creates subjective debates, and makes agency management harder.
It also leads to fragmented advertising. One campaign sells price. Another sells expertise. Another sells lifestyle. Another sells convenience. Another sells quality. Individually, they may perform. Collectively, they build very little.
That's a huge missed opportunity. The most effective marketing compounds meaning. Every campaign should make the next campaign slightly more powerful, because the audience already understands something about you.
That only happens when campaigns pull through from a consistent messaging strategy.
Messaging Should Be a System, Not a Slogan
Good messaging needs more than one magical sentence everyone repeats forever. It needs architecture.
At the top is the core brand idea: the central thought you want associated with the organization. Underneath that are the few strategic messages that explain why that idea is credible and relevant. Then come proof points: capabilities, customer outcomes, stories, evidence, audience-specific value propositions. And finally, campaign expressions.
Think about it as a hierarchy:
That sequence matters. Too many organizations start at the bottom. They ask:
"What should our spring campaign say?"
The better question is:
"Which part of our strategic message should this spring campaign bring to life?"
That subtle shift changes marketing dramatically. Now your campaign is contributing to something larger than itself. Creative teams still have freedom. In fact, they often have more freedom, because the strategic territory is clear. Instead of inventing the strategy, they can focus on making the strategy interesting.
Dove: What Happens When You Keep Building on One Idea for 20 Years
Consider a brand that demonstrates the compounding effect of consistent meaning over time: Dove.
Before: Beauty marketing reinforced a definition Dove's customers didn't believe they fit.
In 2004, Dove commissioned global research into women's relationship with beauty. One result became foundational: only 2% of the women surveyed described themselves as beautiful.4
That insight gave Dove something far more valuable than an advertising concept. It gave the company a tension it could spend decades addressing:
The beauty industry tells women what beauty should look like. Dove believes beauty should include what women actually look like.
That is a messaging platform.
After: One strategic idea produced decades of different campaigns.
Dove launched the Campaign for Real Beauty in 2004, using women who challenged the narrow beauty stereotypes common in advertising at the time. But here's what matters: they didn't abandon the idea when the campaign cycle ended. The idea created more ideas.
"Real Beauty" led to the Dove Self-Esteem Project.
It led to partnerships with schools and organizations.
It led to the famous Evolution film exposing manipulation in beauty advertising.
It led to research.
It led to educational programs.
It led to continuing commitments around how women are portrayed.
And twenty years later, it gave Dove an obvious position on generative AI: the brand pledged never to use AI imagery in place of real women in its advertising.5
Look at what's happening there.
The technology changed.
The channels changed.
The cultural conversation changed.
The campaigns changed.
The meaning didn't.
As early as 2006, Unilever was describing Real Beauty as a global mission producing different regional executions. Its Evolution film was downloaded a million times on YouTube in two weeks; its self-esteem programs had already reached more than 750,000 young people; and Unilever reported that Dove sales were growing rapidly.6 Today, Dove says its Self-Esteem Project has reached more than 100 million young people.5
That's what twenty years of message pull-through looks like.
Why This Matters
Dove demonstrates why organizations shouldn't constantly ask: What's our next big campaign idea? Sometimes the much better question is: What's the next interesting expression of the idea we already own?
When every campaign introduces a new strategic idea, the marketing budget repeatedly pays to establish something that will soon disappear. When campaigns build on an existing idea, the investment compounds.
Customers begin anticipating your point of view.
Employees understand the boundaries of the brand.
Agencies know the creative territory.
Partners understand what you stand for.
Eventually, the audience begins carrying part of the message for you.
The Best Messaging Creates Creative Constraints
Marketers sometimes worry that consistency means repetition. Consistency means coherence.
Nike can tell thousands of stories about thousands of athletes without becoming a different company every week. Patagonia can talk about products, environmental activism, outdoor experiences, repair, consumption, and conservation while still feeling unmistakably like Patagonia.
The execution changes. The worldview doesn't. That's the sweet spot.
Your messaging strategy should create enough constraint that the organization is recognizable, but enough space that creative teams can explore. If every campaign uses exactly the same words, your messaging system is probably too rigid. If every campaign could belong to a different company, it's too loose.
Then Something Interesting Happens Outside Marketing
Once an organization becomes clearer about its messaging, the impact begins moving sideways through the company.
Salespeople get better language. Instead of describing every feature, they understand the larger story those features support.
Recruiters get better language. They can explain not just what jobs exist, but what kind of organization people are joining.
Managers get better language. They can connect everyday decisions to a larger purpose.
Employees understand what the company is trying to be known for. Partners understand what they're participating in. And customers have language they can repeat.
That last one is particularly important. One of the highest forms of marketing is a customer who can explain your brand to someone else. That's customer ambassadorship, and it depends heavily on message clarity.
Think about the companies you recommend easily. You probably have a short explanation for why someone should choose them.
"They're more expensive, but they'll repair it forever."
"They make the whole process unbelievably easy."
"They're the people to call if you have a complicated project."
"They actually understand small businesses."
Those sentences are valuable. They're reputation, compressed into language. Strong organizations intentionally create that kind of clarity.
Messaging Becomes a Decision-Making Tool
This is where the conversation sometimes surprises executives. Messaging sounds like a communications discipline. But at its best, it also functions as a decision-making tool.
Imagine your company is trying to own a position around simplicity. That idea shouldn't live only in advertisements.
Product teams can ask: Are we making this simpler?
Customer service can ask: Did we make this interaction easier?
Sales can ask: Are we explaining this simply?
Leadership can ask: Are our processes reinforcing or contradicting our promise?
The clearest example of this may not come from consumer marketing at all. It comes from healthcare.
Cleveland Clinic: Two Words That Changed How 35,000 Employees Saw Their Jobs
Before: Exceptional medicine didn't automatically create an exceptional experience.
Cleveland Clinic had already established itself as one of the world's most respected healthcare institutions. But leadership recognized an uncomfortable distinction: being excellent at medicine and being excellent at the patient experience aren't necessarily the same thing.
Cleveland Clinic went on to become the first academic medical center to create an Office of Patient Experience, run by a chief experience officer.7 The organization's guiding idea was simple:
Patients First.
There is nothing particularly clever about "Patients First." Its power came from what Cleveland Clinic did next. They operationalized it.
After: Everyone became a "caregiver."
Cleveland Clinic made one small language decision. Physicians were caregivers. Nurses were caregivers. But so were receptionists, administrators, technicians, food-service workers, and maintenance staff. Everyone who could affect the patient's experience became a caregiver.8
It reframed the employee's job. If you're maintaining a hallway, you're contributing to the experience of someone who may be having one of the worst days of their life.
That's messaging affecting performance.
In 2010, Cleveland Clinic began an enterprise-wide cultural initiative called Cleveland Clinic Experience, explicitly designed to connect the employee experience and the patient experience. Nearly 35,000 caregivers ultimately participated in interactive learning sessions. More than 2,000 leaders attended leadership training, and more than 1,350 managers participated in coaching programs. The organization built the principles into new-employee orientation and performance management. Marketing, HR, operations, learning and development, and the Office of Patient Experience all participated.8
That's messaging pull-through at an organizational level.
Patient satisfaction also improved during this period. By the third quarter of 2011, more than 80% of surveyed patients said they would definitely recommend the hospital, “about 20% higher than the national average.”7 Many initiatives contributed to that improvement, so it would be wrong to credit messaging or training alone. But the organization explicitly positioned the Cleveland Clinic Experience initiative as part of its patient-centered transformation.
Why This Matters
"Patients First" isn't powerful because customers see it. It's powerful because employees can make decisions with it.
Should we change this process? Does it put patients first?
Should this employee behavior be rewarded? Does it put patients first?
How should we recover from this service problem? Put the patient first.
At that point, messaging is helping run the organization. That is one of the least appreciated functions of a strong messaging architecture: clear brands reduce decision friction.
People don't need a 40-page policy to resolve every situation if they deeply understand the principle governing the decision. That creates alignment, and aligned organizations require less explanation. Employees make better independent decisions because they understand what the organization is trying to deliver.
There's less "What does leadership want us to do?" and more "Given who we say we are, the answer is obvious." That is a very different level of brand maturity.
Domino's: When the Message Forces the Company to Change
There is another version of messaging alignment that may matter even more. Sometimes the message creates a standard the organization has to live up to. Domino's did this in an unusually public way.
Before: The company had a perception problem it couldn't advertise around.
By the late 2000s, Domino's had a strange brand problem. Consumers understood its delivery proposition. The pizza itself was another story. Domino's later put its customers' criticism on screen, including one now-famous single-word review: "Cardboard."9
A conventional marketing response would have been predictable.
New photography.
New promotional pricing.
"Now better than ever."
Maybe a celebrity chef.
Domino's did almost the opposite. The company listened to the criticism and spent roughly two years reworking the brand and product. It tested dozens of cheeses, 15 sauces and nearly 50 crust seasoning blends, gathering feedback from both customers and people who hadn't ordered Domino's in years.10
Then it built the marketing around an uncomfortable admission: customers said the pizza wasn't good enough, they were right, and Domino's changed it.
After: Transparency became bigger than the campaign.
The resulting Pizza Turnaround campaign featured real criticism and real Domino's employees responding to it. The message was essentially: we listened, we fixed it, now judge for yourself.
And that idea spread far beyond advertising. Domino's said the reinvention involved everyone from its CEO and franchisees to supply-chain teams, suppliers, product developers and marketers.10 The company subsequently extended the same transparency philosophy into other marketing decisions. When it dropped retouched food photography in 2010, for example, Domino's said the move followed "the same line of transparency" that began with Pizza Turnaround.11
The campaign had created a principle, and the principle started generating more campaigns.
Domino's reported 9.9% domestic same-store sales growth in 2010. Its CEO called it the year "we demonstrated that we're a new Domino's," and the company credited more store traffic, the improved pizza and its advertising.12
Messaging wasn't solely responsible. Domino's actually improved the pizza, and that's the point: great messaging creates organizational accountability. If your brand says one thing loudly enough, eventually the company has to behave accordingly.
Why This Matters
Domino's demonstrates an important progression:
The communication turned the turnaround into a public promise, and a public promise is hard to walk back inside the company.
Closer to Home: The Same Problem at Local Scale
Everything above happened at enormous scale, so it would be fair to read it as a Fortune 500 problem, one that takes a hundred agencies and a nine-figure media budget.
But I've spent the last decade working with and inside a family-owned powersports dealership, and the same pattern played out there.
Before: competing on the two things everyone claims.
The dealership was doing well. It also wasn't close to its potential, and the reason was in its own positioning.
It was positioned on price and service: the best value in town, and better customer care than the guy down the road. Both claims were defensible. Both were also what every competing dealership in the market said about itself. The positioning distinguished nothing. It entered the company into an argument it could never definitively win.
And that framing had traveled inward, the same way Patients First did at Cleveland Clinic, only pointed the wrong way.
Sales conversations led with specifications and technical expertise, because the company's positioning said it competed on product and price. The service department measured itself in hours, not in whether a family lost a summer weekend. The detail shop did clean work without much sense of who the work was for.
Nobody was doing anything wrong. Everyone was optimizing correctly for what the organization had implicitly told them it was.
That's the quiet cost of undecided messaging: it instructs employees, whether or not anyone chose the instruction.
After: deciding what the business was actually for.
We started with a mission, vision and values workshop: the unglamorous work of getting ownership and the leadership team to decide what the business was for.
What came out of it was a single idea the dealership could own:
The elite family boat dealership that genuinely cares about your family.
The reframe underneath it was the important part. The customer isn't a boat buyer. The customer is a steward of their family's memories, and the dealership is the family that helps make those memories possible.
That idea had a property the old positioning never did: everyone could find themselves in it. The college kid working in the detail shop remembers being on the water with his own family growing up. He doesn't need a training module to understand what he's contributing to.
From there we built the architecture:
We SERVICE boats to KEEP you on the water.
We build PROGRAMS that keep boating about memories, not the headaches of ownership.
Then came the pull-through, which is where most companies quit.
Brand messaging guides went out to vendors. Employee handbooks were rebuilt around the mission, vision and values. Salespeople took the edge off transactional rhetoric and started asking how to get a family on the water. The service department stopped thinking in billable hours and started thinking about how fast it could give a family its summer back.
Then the idea started generating things nobody had planned:
An annual customer appreciation event, so customers could meet other boaters and make more memories together.
A referral program, because boating is better with friends.
Premium safety equipment included with every purchase, so the day carries less worry and more memory.
Testimonial videos, in customers' own words.
None of those were on a marketing calendar. They fell out of the idea once the idea was clear.
The dealership went on to earn one of the industry's national dealer-excellence certifications, held by only a small share of dealers. Customer reviews grew by more than half in a single year, and its public rating climbed from the mid-fours to a solid 5.0, among the best-reviewed dealers in its category. Over the same stretch it beat its major unit sales targets by double digits in consecutive seasons, in a market contracting hard enough that competitors around it were closing.13
As with every other example in this piece, messaging alone didn't produce those numbers. A great deal changed at once: inventory strategy, new websites, an acquisition, entirely new programs. But the review data matters most here, because reviews are the closest thing we have to a direct measurement of whether customers actually experienced what a brand promised. The story changed, the organization changed with it, and customers noticed and said so publicly.
Today the dealership is known as an elite but down-to-earth place that puts family and care into everything it does, and it earned that by demonstrating it, repeatedly, from every direction.
Why This Matters
This is the same architecture IBM and Cleveland Clinic built, at a tiny fraction of the scale:
And small companies have an advantage they rarely recognize. Pull-through is faster when the whole company fits in one building. The distance between deciding what you mean and having everyone act on it can be measured in weeks rather than years.
The Goal Isn't Consistent Communication. It's Consistent Meaning.
Organizations sometimes pursue consistency by policing words. Use this phrase. Don't use that phrase. Here are the approved headlines. Here is the tagline. That can help, but language is only the surface. The real goal is consistent meaning.
Your CEO, salesperson, recruiter, customer service rep, website, advertising campaign, investor presentation, and customer should all be capable of describing the organization differently while communicating essentially the same idea.
That's when messaging becomes institutionalized. And when that happens, marketing gets dramatically easier.
Campaign strategy becomes clearer.
Creative briefs get sharper.
Agency relationships improve.
Content gets more focused.
Sales enablement gets stronger.
Customer experiences feel more intentional.
Employee decisions become more aligned.
And every impression starts contributing to the same reputation.
So How Do You Fix It?
Start upstream. Before rewriting your website or launching the next campaign, answer a few strategic questions as an organization:
What do we want to be known for?
What do our best customers actually value about us?
What do we believe about our industry or customers that shapes how we operate?
What meaningful difference can we credibly claim?
What evidence proves it?
What three or four ideas should show up repeatedly across our communication?
And what should customers be able to say about us after experiencing the brand?
Then build those answers into a messaging architecture. Not a 70-page brand book no one opens. A working system.
Something marketing can use when writing a campaign brief.
Something sales can use in a prospecting call.
Something leadership can use in a presentation.
Something HR can use in recruiting.
Something an agency can understand in twenty minutes.
Then comes the discipline that matters most: pull it through.
Into your website.
Into your paid campaigns.
Into social.
Into events.
Into sales presentations.
Into onboarding.
Into recruiting.
Into customer experience.
Into internal meetings.
Into the stories leadership tells.
Because messaging only becomes powerful through repetition. Not mindless repetition of buzzwords that could apply to any organization anywhere. Strategic repetition of messaging that is unique to you. The kind where people encounter the same central idea from enough different directions that eventually they stop thinking of it as something your company says. They simply think of it as who your company is.
And that's the real job of messaging. Not finding prettier words. Not writing a clever tagline. Not filling a brand guidelines document. It's creating shared meaning, inside and outside the organization, and making sure every campaign, conversation, and experience adds another piece of evidence.
When that happens, marketing stops feeling like an endless series of disconnected campaigns and starts building something greater than the sum of its parts. Each piece stands on the last, and over time it cements:
A position.
A reputation.
A culture.
A brand.
And unlike your next campaign, those assets compound.
What These Stories Share
Look again at what these five organizations did.
IBM sold enterprise technology.
Domino's sold pizza.
Cleveland Clinic delivered healthcare.
Dove sold personal-care products.
A family-owned dealership sold boats.
Completely different industries and budgets. But the pattern holds. They reduced a complicated organization to a clearer strategic idea. Then they allowed that idea to travel.
Domino's: listen and improve → product development → employees → advertising → transparency → customer trust.
Cleveland Clinic: Patients First → employee identity → training → management → performance → patient experience.
Dove: Real Beauty → advertising → research → partnerships → social programs → brand standards → advocacy.
The dealership: family memories → mission and values → employee behavior → service programs → customer experience → reviews and referrals.
That's messaging architecture in practice.
And the lesson isn't that your organization needs an "e-business," a "Patients First," or a "Real Beauty" tagline. The lesson is that the strongest organizations identify a small number of strategically important ideas and then relentlessly create evidence for them.
Most marketing teams do the opposite. They create evidence first —
a campaign,
a headline,
a video,
an event,
a sales deck,
a social post —
and then try to figure out what all of it adds up to.
Great brands reverse the sequence.
Decide what you want to mean.
Then make the organization prove it.
Again.
And again.
And again.
Until eventually the market stops thinking of it as your messaging. They simply think of it as true.
That's the work I care about most at Graystone: helping values-led companies find the few ideas worth owning, the ones that come out of what they stand for, and pulling them through everything the organization says and does.
Sources
- American Association of Advertising Agencies, “IBM consolidates account with Ogilvy & Mather” (1994, the $500 million account moved from several agencies to one).
- Associated Press via The Spokesman-Review, January 24, 1995 (“It lost $8.1 billion in 1993”).
- IBM, “e-business”, IBM History ($500 million campaign; 10,000+ clients by 1999; unaided association 7x the nearest competitor; 1994–2000 revenue and net income; Gerstner quote).
- Angela Celebre and Ashley Waggoner Denton, “The good, the bad, and the ugly of the Dove Campaign for Real Beauty,” In-Mind, 2014, citing Etcoff et al., The Real Truth About Beauty: A Global Report (2004).
- Dove, “Real Beauty Pledge” (AI imagery commitment; Self-Esteem Project reach).
- Unilever, Annual Review 2006, “Brands with global missions.”
- Julie Ritzer Ross, “Change for the Better: Cleveland Clinic Improves the Patient Experience,” HealthExec.
- Cleveland Clinic, Focus on the Patient Experience, Spring 2011.
- “Domino’s New Recipe: Brutal Truth in Advertising,” Time, May 2011.
- Domino’s Pizza, “Celebrating 50th Year, Domino’s Pizza Gives Itself a Makeover,” December 16, 2009.
- Domino’s Pizza, “Domino’s Pizza Continuing Transparency… This Time, Through Photography,” July 5, 2010.
- Domino’s Pizza, “Domino’s Pizza Announces 2010 Financial Results,” March 1, 2011.
- Graystone client results. See the Proof page.
If your organization is ready to decide what it wants to mean — and then prove it — that's exactly what I do.
Thirty minutes, no pitch. Tell me what you're working on and I'll tell you honestly whether the problem is marketing at all — and whether I'm the right person for it.